New Cert Petition on Derivative Sovereign Immunity Appeals
A new cert petition asks whether the denial of derivative sovereign immunity is immediately appealable via the collateral-order doctrine.
Derivative sovereign immunity (also sometimes referred to as the Yearsly doctrine) is a defense that government contractors sometimes raise to defeat claims stemming from work the contractors did for the government. The courts of appeals have split on whether a denial of that defense is immediately appealable.
I’ve covered a few of those decisions in prior roundups. Among them is the Sixth Circuit’s decision in ACT, Inc. v. Worldwide Interactive Network, Inc., which I thought focused too much whether a defense is an immunity and overlooked the rest of the collateral-order doctrine. There’s also the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Childs v. San Diego Family Housing LLC, in which the court said that the interests protected by derivative sovereign immunity aren’t sufficiently important to be effectively unreviewable in normal post-final-judgment appeal. And then there’s the Tenth Circuit’s decision in Menocal v. GEO Group, Inc., from which this petition stems. I think the Tenth Circuit’s decision is particularly interesting, as the court said that the defense is not sufficiently separate from the merits to be appealable via the collateral-order doctrine.
The case is GEO Group, Inc. v. Menocal. The response is due February 18, 2025. Also of note, the Supreme Court denied cert on this issue a few years ago.
Petition for Writ of Certiorari, GEO Group, Inc. v. Menocal, (Jan. 13, 2025), available at the Supreme Court and Westlaw
Final Decisions PLLC is an appellate boutique and consultancy that focuses on federal appellate jurisdiction. We partner with lawyers facing appellate-jurisdiction issues, working as consultants or co-counsel to achieve positive outcomes on appeal. Contact us to learn how we can work together.
Learn More ContactRelated Posts
Recent Posts
A new cert petition asks whether the denial of derivative sovereign immunity is immediately appealable via the collateral-order doctrine. Derivative sovereign immunity (also sometimes referred to as the Yearsly doctrine) is a defense that government contractors sometimes raise to defeat claims stemming from work the contractors did for the government. The courts of appeals have […]
Continue reading....
Disclosure: I filed an amicus brief in the Fourth Circuit in support of rehearing its decision in this case and discussed the cert petition with the petitioner’s counsel. Last week, the Supreme Court granted certiorari in Parrish v. United States. The case asks if a would-be appellant must file a second notice of appeal after […]
Continue reading....
I’m thrilled to announce the creation of Final Decisions PLLC, an appellate boutique and consultancy focused on appellate jurisdiction. Through it, I hope to partner with lawyers facing complex appellate-jurisdiction issues. Almost six years ago, I started the Final Decisions blog as a way to keep on top of developments in the world of appellate […]
Continue reading....
In New Albany Main Street Properties v. Watco Companies, LLC, the Sixth Circuit held that it could not review a decision granting leave to amend as part of a qualified-immunity appeal. The leave-to-amend decision was not itself immediately appealable. Nor could it tag along with the denial of immunity (which technically involved qualified immunity under […]
Continue reading....
In Ashley v. Clay County, the Fifth Circuit held that a municipal defendant could appeal a district court’s refusal to resolve an immunity defense despite the district court’s ordering arbitration.
Continue reading....