Posts tagged “Dismissals Without Prejudice”


Last week, the en banc Fifth Circuit heard argument in Williams v. Taylor Seidenbach, Inc. The case gives that court the opportunity to clean up the “finality trap” it has created for litigants. The Fifth Circuit has held that parties may not appeal when they’ve voluntarily dismissed some of their claims without prejudice; the voluntary dismissal precludes the district court’s decision from being final.…

Continue reading....

Update: For my full post on the argument in Williams, see The Fifth Circuit & the Finality Trap.

The en banc Fifth Circuit heard argument this morning in Williams v. Taylor Seidenbach, Inc. The case addresses the finality and appealability of an action when some claims have been decided on the merits but others have been voluntarily dismissed without prejudice.…

Continue reading....

The courts of appeals occasionally struggle with appellate jurisdiction when parties dismiss some of their claims without prejudice. The issue comes up when a district court has resolved some of the claims in a multi-claim suit and parties try to transform that non-final decision into a final one by dismissing their remaining claims without prejudice.…

Continue reading....

Update: The Fifth Circuit granted rehearing en banc, and argument is scheduled for January 23, 2020.

I’ve jokingly characterized the Supreme Court’s decision in Microsoft v. Baker as creating a zombie action: one that is over in the district court but not final—and never will be final—for purposes of appeal. (The joke kills at cocktail parties.)…

Continue reading....

Final Decisions PLLC is an appellate boutique and consultancy that focuses on federal appellate jurisdiction. We partner with lawyers facing appellate-jurisdiction issues, working as consultants or co-counsel to achieve positive outcomes on appeal. Contact us to learn how we can work together.

Learn More Contact